Hagerty, Inc. (HGTY) Valuation — DCF, Graham & Comparables

Hagerty, Inc. (HGTY) — Price $15.58 (closing price, October 30, 2026) — Financial Services — Insurance - Property & Casualty — NYSE

Latest reported results:

Valuation dashboard for Hagerty, Inc. (HGTY) with P/E N/A, P/B 5.28, EV/EBITDA 70.6 and dividend yield 0.00%. DCF, Graham Number, EPS growth, peer multiples and dividend discount models plus sector comparison against other Financial Services companies.

Hagerty, Inc. operates globally, serving as an insurance agency that specializes in policies for automobiles and boats, in addition to offering reinsurance products. Beyond its core insurance offerings, the company provides a suite of services and platforms: Hagerty Media distributes content through its HDC Magazine, various video productions, and a dedicated YouTube channel.

What would it be worth at its usual multiples?

Versus its usual multiples: expensive · Current P/B 5.3× · Multiples range: $4.43 · $5.90.

At a P/B justified by its ROE 9.8 % (1.5×) $4 (-72 %); at its peers' median (2.0×) $6 (-62 %). Implied price from applying the reference multiples to today's earnings (or book value, or FFO) per share. Not a fair value: it is where the stock would trade at its usual multiples.

Analysis Summary

Hagerty, Inc. reported revenue of $1.46B in the most recent fiscal year, growing at a 5-year CAGR of 23.9%. Net income reached $49.0M, with a 37.0% 5-year CAGR.

Trailing-twelve-month margins: gross margin 75.2%, operating margin 2.4%, net margin 1.8%.

At $15.58 (closing price, October 30, 2026), HGTY trades at a P/E of 158.49 and an ROE of 9.81%. Market capitalisation stands at $5.4B.

Balance sheet quality for HGTY: debt-to-equity ratio of 0.87, current ratio of 0.00 over the last 12 months. A debt-to-equity below 1.0 typically signals conservative capital structure, while a current ratio above 1.5 indicates comfortable short-term liquidity.

Valuation Ratios

P/E Ratio158.49
Price / Book5.28
EV / EBITDA70.6
Dividend Yield0.00%

Peer Comparison

SymbolCompanyMarket CapP/EP/BROE
HGTYHagerty, Inc.$5.4B158.495.289.8%
SIGISelective Insurance Group, Inc.$5.9B11.881.7014.3%
TCBITexas Capital Bancshares, Inc.$3.9B11.591.1110.1%
TFSLTFS Financial Corporation$4.6B45.442.285.2%
CRVLCorVel Corporation$4.2B36.5410.2229.9%
MCYMercury General Corporation$5.7B6.052.0037.2%
CNOCNO Financial Group, Inc.$5.3B13.112.2916.6%
AGOAssured Guaranty Ltd.$3.1B9.650.566.3%

Price

Price$15.58 (closing price, October 30, 2026)
Market Cap$5.4B
ExchangeNYSE
CountryUS

Profitability

Return on Equity9.81%
Return on Invested Capital2.36%
Return on Assets1.19%
Gross Margin75.24%
Operating Margin2.45%
Net Margin1.81%

Related companies: SIGI · TCBI · TFSL · CRVL · MCY · CNO · AGO · PJT

Explore sector: Financial Services · Insurance - Property & Casualty

More sections of HGTY: Overview · Financials · Statistics · Estimates · Technical · Ownership · News · Events

Discover more: Weekly Radar: the S&P 500 through the Buffett and Lynch methods · Companies that pass the Buffett method · Companies that pass the Lynch method · Stocks that pass Graham's defensive investor test today · Investment Academy — learn to analyze stocks